Story First seen 10 outlets 11 headlines: 5 Liberal4 Neutral2 Conservative
Donald Trump Moves to Make His Oval Office Makeover Permanent
How 10 outlets across the spectrum covered this story.
Topics:Donald Trump
Last updated Today’s headlinesAll stories covered from all sides
How the coverage differs
The story, as the headlines establish it, is that President Donald Trump has signed a proclamation or executive order designating the Oval Office — and, according to The Hill, the Cabinet Room as well — as a national monument. Newsweek frames the action in terms of the president's redecoration of the room, describing it as a move "to Make His Oval Office Makeover Permanent."
All five headlines agree on the core fact: Trump took formal executive action concerning the status of the Oval Office. The Hill and the New York Post both specify a signed instrument, a "proclamation" and an "EO" respectively, while the New York Times and Townhall describe the outcome rather than the mechanism, as making the room "a National Monument" or "a National Landmark."
The differences are mostly in tone and in what each outlet treats as the point of the action. The New York Times offers the most stripped-down version, noting only the monument designation without reference to Trump's renovations. Newsweek centers the "Makeover," tying the legal designation to the president's personal redecorating. Townhall's "Turns Oval Office Into a National Landmark" presents the move as a straightforward, settled accomplishment, while the New York Post is the most colloquial and the only headline to introduce doubt, joking that the order will "keep Oval Office from becoming a square" while noting the "fate of prez's gilded remodel up in the air" — simultaneously flagging the gold decor and suggesting it may not be protected.
The headlines do not make clear what a national monument designation legally entails for a room inside the White House, whether the president's specific decorative changes are covered by it, who might otherwise alter the room, or why the action was taken now.
Liberal
-
Trump signs order to make gold-decorated Oval Office a national monument – video
-
‘Learned Nothing’: Trump's Truly Oblivious Oval Office Announcement Has Critics Fuming
-
Trump signs proclamation declaring Oval Office a national monument
-
Trump signs proclamation to try to prevent changes to gold-covered Oval Office
-
Trump Moves to Make Oval Office a National Monument